Skip to Content

Welcome!

Share and discuss the best content and new marketing ideas, build your professional profile and become a better marketer together.

Sign up

The political landscape, particularly the attacks on higher education funding during the Trump era, has underscored the vulnerability of relying solely on traditional public support for university research. To ensure resilience and continued discovery, we need to think creatively about funding.

This space is for discussing and developing alternative funding models for graduate research. We've gathered a diverse set of initial ideas aiming to be both practical and forward-thinking – think research spin-offs, industry consortia, community partnerships, crowdfunding, direct support programs, and more.

We need your collective intelligence to move these from brainstorm to potential reality. Please:

  • Explore the ideas listed in this forum.
  • Vote for those you find most compelling. (at the bottom of each post)

  • Share your insights: What are the strengths, weaknesses, potential pitfalls, or ways to improve each concept?
  • Contribute your own suggestions. (At the bottom of each post using the comments options!)

Let's build a diverse portfolio of funding strategies to empower the next generation of research!

You need to be registered to interact with the community.
This question has been flagged
24 Views

Core Concept

This initiative involves creating and distributing specialized, value-added content derived from university research—such as curated newsletters summarizing key findings across a field, in-depth analytical reports, timely updates on research progress, access to pre-publication summaries (not necessarily full papers), licensed access to specific curated datasets, or exclusive expert briefings/webinars. 

Access to this premium content is offered on a recurring subscription basis (monthly or annual fee) primarily targeting audiences with a specific professional or deep personal interest (e.g., industry analysts, R&D professionals, policymakers, dedicated enthusiasts). 

The model aims to generate revenue to support the research group or center producing the content, while carefully operating within the bounds of open access principles and funder mandates by charging for curation, synthesis, early summaries, or specialized analysis rather than fundamental research findings.

Implementation Strategy & Key Steps

  • Phase 1: Planning & Design:
    • Identify Niche & Audience: Determine specific research areas or analytical capabilities within the university where curated, timely, or in-depth information holds significant value for an identifiable external audience willing to pay. Define this target audience precisely (e.g., biotech analysts, renewable energy policy advisors, specific patient advocacy groups).

    • Define Content & Value Proposition: Specify the exact content offerings (e.g., weekly industry brief, monthly deep-dive report, quarterly data analysis package, access to expert Q&A forum). Clearly articulate why this content is worth paying for compared to freely available information (e.g., timeliness, curation, expert analysis, convenience, exclusive insights).

    • Platform & Pricing: Select a suitable subscription management platform (e.g., Substack, Memberful, Patreon, or build functionality onto a university website using tools like Stripe). Develop tiered subscription levels if appropriate (e.g., individual vs. corporate, basic vs. premium access) and set pricing based on value, target audience willingness to pay, and cost recovery needs.

    • Content Workflow & Policies: Establish a workflow for content creation, review (including scientific accuracy and compliance checks), and distribution. Assign roles (faculty experts, dedicated writers/analysts, admin support). Critically, develop internal guidelines ensuring compliance with university open access policies and specific funder mandates (e.g., NIH Public Access Policy). Define rules for sharing pre-publication information appropriately. Secure internal approvals (Department, Research Office, potentially Communications/Development).

  • Phase 2: Launch & Promotion:
    • Platform Setup & Sample Content: Build the subscription webpage/platform, integrate payment processing, and create high-quality sample content to showcase value.

    • Targeted Marketing: Launch the subscription service to the defined target audience using appropriate channels (e.g., professional networking sites like LinkedIn, relevant industry conferences/publications, targeted email lists, social media groups, partnerships with related organizations). Consider offering limited-time introductory rates or founding member benefits.

    • Onboarding: Create a smooth process for new subscribers to sign up, access content, and manage their accounts.

  • Phase 3: Ongoing Operation & Refinement:
    • Consistent Content Delivery: Adhere strictly to the promised content production and delivery schedule. Maintain high quality and relevance.

    • Subscriber Management: Manage subscriber list, handle billing inquiries and customer service, monitor renewals and churn.

    • Growth & Engagement: Continuously market the service to attract new subscribers. Engage with current subscribers (e.g., surveys, Q&A sessions, comment sections) to foster community and gather feedback.

    • Analysis & Adaptation: Monitor key metrics (subscriber numbers, revenue, churn rate, content engagement). Use data and feedback to refine content strategy, pricing, and platform features. Ensure ongoing compliance with all relevant policies.

Key Stakeholders & Roles

  • Internal:
    • Content Creators (Faculty, Researchers, Analysts, Writers): Develop, write, or curate the specialized content. Provide expertise.

    • Program Manager/Editor: Oversees content calendar, manages production workflow, ensures quality/consistency, handles platform administration, manages subscriber communications. (Could be dedicated staff or assigned within a lab/center).

    • University Communications/Marketing: Advises on branding, develops marketing strategy, assists with promotion.

    • Office of Research: Provides policy oversight, ensures compliance with open access/funder mandates and research ethics.

    • Technology Transfer Office (TTO): Involved if subscription includes licensed access to specific university IP (data, software).

    • Finance Office: Manages revenue collection, processes payments, handles accounting and fund distribution.

    • Legal Counsel: Reviews subscriber terms of service, platform agreements, data privacy compliance, IP licensing terms (if applicable).

    • University Library: Advises on open access best practices and compliance.

  • External:
    • Subscribers: Individuals, professionals, corporate R&D or market intelligence departments, libraries, policymakers paying for access.

    • Subscription Platform Provider: (If using a third-party service like Substack, Memberful).

    • Payment Processor: (e.g., Stripe, PayPal).

Resource Requirements

  • Personnel: Dedicated and consistent effort for content creation is paramount. This requires time from faculty experts and/or dedicated writers, analysts, or curators. Administrative time is needed for platform management, subscriber service, billing, and marketing.

  • Financial: Revenue comes from subscriptions. Start-up costs may include platform setup, initial marketing push, content development time before launch. Ongoing costs include personnel time, platform fees (if applicable), payment processing fees (typically % of revenue), and marketing budget.

  • Infrastructure/Technology: A reliable subscription management platform with secure payment processing capabilities. Content creation and editing tools. Email marketing platform for newsletters and subscriber communication. A professional-looking website or landing page for the service.

  • Policy/Administrative: Crucial need for clear university policies addressing: external sales of information, faculty/staff effort allocation, strict compliance with open access mandates, guidelines for sharing pre-publication info, IP ownership of created content/reports, application of F&A to subscription revenue (requires specific policy decision), data privacy for subscribers (GDPR/CCPA relevant), and use of university branding. A clear subscriber agreement (Terms of Service) is required.

Potential Challenges & Mitigation

  • Content Quality & Consistency: Maintaining a high standard and regular delivery schedule for specialized content requires significant ongoing effort.
    • Mitigation: Dedicate specific personnel resources (don't rely solely on spare faculty time); develop a realistic editorial calendar and workflow; establish quality control/review processes; potentially repurpose internal analyses or reports.

  • Subscriber Acquisition & Retention: Attracting paying subscribers in a world of free information; demonstrating enough value to prevent cancellations (churn).
    • Mitigation: Target a well-defined niche audience with specific unmet needs; deliver truly unique and high-value content (curation, analysis, timeliness); build community among subscribers; actively solicit feedback; offer tiered options; ensure excellent customer service.

  • Conflict with Open Access: Risk of violating funder mandates or appearing to inappropriately restrict access to publicly funded research.
    • Mitigation: Zero tolerance for violating funder mandates. University policy must enforce this. Focus paid content strictly on value-added layers: synthesis, deep analysis, curated summaries, early access briefs (with full results released openly on schedule), licensed datasets not subject to mandates, exclusive expert interaction. Be transparent about open access commitments.

  • Pricing: Setting the right price to maximize revenue without deterring potential subscribers.
    • Mitigation: Analyze target audience's budget/willingness to pay; research pricing of comparable niche information products (newsletters, industry reports); consider value delivered; test different price points or offer introductory rates.

  • Platform Management: Technical aspects of managing subscriptions, payments, access control.
    • Mitigation: Choose established, reliable third-party platforms designed for this purpose; ensure good technical support; automate billing and access management functions.

  • Internal Resource Allocation: Securing necessary faculty/staff time and administrative support for content creation and management.
    • Mitigation: Demonstrate potential revenue and strategic value; develop a clear business plan; ensure roles and responsibilities are well-defined; explore revenue-sharing models to incentivize participation where appropriate and allowed by policy.

Success Metrics & Evaluation

  • Financial: Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) / Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR), total subscribers, subscriber growth rate, customer lifetime value (CLTV), churn rate, Average Revenue Per User (ARPU), profitability (revenue minus all costs).

  • Engagement: Content open/click rates, download rates, webinar attendance, time spent on platform, subscriber feedback/comments/satisfaction scores.

  • Reach: Number and type (professional roles, industries) of subscribers attracted.

  • Impact: Anecdotal or survey evidence of subscribers finding the content valuable and useful in their work or understanding.

  • Evaluation: Regular (e.g., monthly) tracking of key financial and engagement metrics. Quarterly or semi-annual strategic reviews assessing profitability, content effectiveness, subscriber feedback, compliance, and overall contribution to the research unit's funding and outreach goals.

University Policy Considerations

  • External Sales & Service Policy: Framework for selling information products developed by university units.

  • Faculty/Staff Effort & Compensation: Rules on allocating paid effort towards creating commercial subscription content.

  • Open Access Policy: Paramount. Must explicitly define boundaries between mandated open dissemination and permissible premium/value-added content. Requires rigorous compliance check.

  • Intellectual Property Policy: Ownership of curated reports, analyses, newsletters created for the service; terms for licensing any underlying university data or IP included in the subscription.

  • F&A (Indirect Cost) Policy: Specific decision needed on whether/how F&A rates apply to subscription revenue.

  • Use of University Name/Branding: Guidelines for marketing the subscription service.

  • Data Privacy Policy: Protecting subscriber personal and payment information (compliance with GDPR, CCPA etc. is essential).

  • Financial Policies: Procedures for handling recurring revenue, payment processing, refunds, and distribution of net proceeds.

  • Publication & Pre-Publication Data Sharing Policy: Rules governing the timing and scope of sharing findings, ensuring compliance with embargoes and confidentiality where appropriate, while respecting open access timelines.


Avatar
Discard